The Value of Original Window Repair and Retrofit: Studies and Research
The issue of the retention of original windows in preservation, and lately, in sustainability, is of such importancethat it merits its own web page. It is commonly asked where the arguments are to defend original windows, and how to respond to calls forwindow replacement. The perception of preservationists is that there is a large replacement window industry advertising the attractiveness, the no maintenance, and the energy efficiency of a new window, but no one to promote the attractiveness and energy efficiency of a properly maintained original window. Occasional maintenance is required of a historic window; they were built to be reasonably maintained by the owner of the building. New windows are no maintenance because when they break, they have to be replaced. Maintenance is not possible for a modern window.
Lately, new pressure to replace windows is felt from the green products and third party energy certification industries, which emphasize the energy efficiency of new windows and encourage their installation. To their credit, third party certifiers are beginning to acknowledge that repaired windows have equal value to replacement windows in their point rating systems, or are measuring the efficiency of the building envelope as a whole.
Many studies demonstrate the viability of repairing original windows. Some of them are collected here. All of the studies conclude that original window repair and other conservation strategies provide similar energy benefits of a replacement window, with less impact to the environment as an existing resource.
The national Window Preservation Standards book catalogs specific methods for the assessment, maintenance, repair, preservation and weatherization of older and historic wooden windows. Many detailed methods, procedures and materials are included, as well as basic strategies for saving older and historic windows.
Topics include the Window Preservation Standards Collaborative, guiding principles for window preservation work, window part names and definitions, organizing and planning window preservation projects, and how to use the Standards.
Methods include surveying and assessing conditions, glazing, painting, wood repairs, weatherization updates, storm windows and maintenance with many more. Each treatment standard has a brief description of a specific method with appropriate use, a step-by-step procedure that shows what is done and materials are listed. A special section describes how to judge the character of the completed work with easy observations and simple tests to assure the best quality work.
The results of energy performance testing done at the 2011 National Window Preservation Summit are included. It confirms what is already known: Save the primary sash and frame, add weatherstripping and a storm to make the window meet or exceed current performance standards for air infiltration. All the details are in the book, including which energy upgrade methods worked best.
The Window Preservation Standards book is a non-profit project done in partnership with the Preservation Trades Network, Kentucky Heritage Council and Kentucky Preservation. Ordering information can be found here.
A report just produced by the National Trust for Historic Preservation Green Lab provides cost guidance for homeowners weighing the financial and energy tradeoffs between replacing or repairing older, less efficient windows. This report, "Saving Windows, Saving Money: Evaluating the Energy Performance of Window Retrofit and Replacement", builds on previous research by examining multiple window improvement options, comparing them to replacement windows across multiple climate regions.
Saving Windows, Saving Moneys key findings offer homeowners, contractors, architects and others with compelling evidence of the merits of retrofitting windows as opposed to outright replacement.
Key findings include:
Retrofit measures can achieve performance results comparable to new replacement windows. This study shows that there are readily available retrofit measures that can achieve energy savings close to new, high performance replacement windows when the performance for each upgrade option is taken into account.
Almost every retrofit option Offers a better Return on Investment (ROI) than replacement windows. Findings from the cost analysis showed that new, high performance windows are by far the most expensive measure, costing at least double that of common retrofit options when considering materials, installation and general construction commonly required for an existing home. In all climate zones analyzed, cellular shades, interior storm panels and various exterior storm window configurations offer a higher average return on investment compared to new, efficient replacement windows.
The Bottom Line. Retrofitting windows with high performance enhancements can result in substantial energy savings across a variety of climate zones. Selecting options that retain and retrofit existing windows are the most cost effective way to achieve these energy savings and to lower a homes carbon footprint. Retrofits extend the life of existing windows, avoid production of new materials, reduce waste and preserve a homes character.
WINDOW PRESERVATION STANDARDS COLLABORATIVE
In the Fall of 2010, the top preservation trades people in North America and Europe met for the International Preservation Trades Workshop in Frankfort, Kentucky. Among the gathered were some of the top window restoration experts in the country. Five of these window experts, Duffy Hoffman, John Leeke, Jim Turner, David Gibney and Bob Yapp met and decided it was time to create national standards for the repair and weatherization of old and historic windows.
Using cutting-edge window testing technology, theCollaborative's testsare verifying "what most people in historic preservation have known for years, old and historic windows can cost effectively be made as or more energy efficient than new, disposable replacement windows."
The National Trust for Historic Preservation's Weatherization Guide for Older and Historic Buildings includes guidance on why and how to care for older and historic windows:
"Window Repair, Rehabilitation and Replacement" , Peter Baker, P.E.
This report was prepared for Building America, Building Technologies Program, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, U.S. Department of Energy to evaluate advanced retrofit measures. A balanced approach is presented to guide contractors and homeowners to decide whether to repair or replace considering many factors, one of which is historic preservation. November 2011
"A Comparative Study of the Cumulative Energy Use of Historical Versus Contemporary Windows" By Frank Shirley, AIA, Fred Gamble, PhD, Jarod Galvin, RA, LEED AP
This study compares the life-cycle costs of two residential window systems in a pre-1940 house in Boston, Massachusetts. One is an original double-hung window with a new triple-track storm unit. The other is a new, vinyl, double-hung replacement window. Results are obtained from an algorithm that yields the total present value of all costs associated with a window system over its entire life, including acquisition, installation, maintenance, and energy. December 2010
"Field Evaluation of Low-E Storm Windows" By S. Craig Drumheller- NAHB Research Center, Christian Kohler- Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Stefanie Minen-Utilivate Technologies
A field evaluation comparing the performance of low emittance (low-e) storm windows with both standard clear storm windows and no storm windows was performed in a cold climate. Six homes with single pane windows were monitored over the period of one heating season. The homes were monitored with no storm windows and with new storm windows. Simple paybacks for the addition of the storm windows were 10 years for the clear glass and 4.5 years for the low-e storm windows. December 2007
"The Effects of Energy Efficiency Treatments on Historic Windows" by Larry Kinney and Amy Ellsworth January 2011
This study focused on empirical testing of the energy efficiency and economy of a range of options for upgrading the energy performance of historic windows. The study involved retrofitting windows in a test home in a historic district in Boulder, Colorado. It included testing in a window laboratory facility developed for the study.
"Thermal Performance of Traditional Windows" by Dr. Paul Baker for Historic Scotland Revised September 2010
Technical Paper 1 tested the use of curtains, shutters, blinds, and secondary glazing. All were shown to reduce the heat loss through the glazing to varying degrees. Secondary glazing was found to be the most effective overall option, as it reduced heat loss through the window by 63%. Timber shutters are the most effective option of the traditional methods, reducing heat loss by 51%; curtains reduced heat loss by 14%; a Victorian roller blind reduced heat loss by 28%; a modern roller blind reduced heat loss by 22%. The greatest reductions in heat loss came from combining these measures (i.e. blinds, shutters and curtains all closed) and by adding extra insulation to these options.
"Slim-profile double-glazing in listed buildings: Re-measuring the thermal performance" by Nicholas Heath & Paul Baker, Historic Scotland 2013
Technical Paper 20 remeasures the efficiency of previously installed slim-profile double glazing in existing historic windows.
"Thermal Assessment of internal Shutters and Window Film Applied to Traditional Single Glazed Sash and Case Windows" by John Currie, Julio Bros Williamson, Jon Stinson & Marie Jonnard, Historic Scotland
Technical Report 23 assesses the effectiveness of two inexpensive and minimally invasive methods for improving the thermal performance of single glazed windows. This technical paper demonstrates that a range of options, including minimally invasive and inexpensive methods, can play a worthwhile role in the overall thermal improvement of buildings.
"Thermal Performance of Historic Windows" by Chris Wood, http://www.buildingconservation.com (England)
"An Analysis of the Thermal Performance of Repaired and Replacement Windows", PDF, Robert Score and Bradford Carpenter, APT Bulletin 40:2, 2009
Window Energy Analysis, Keith Haberern, P.E.
Replacement Windows and Furnaces in the Heartland: Indianas Energy Conservation Financial Assistance Program by William H. Hill. This is the 1990 study that demonstrates a four hundred year payback using replacement windows.
Measured Winter Performance of Storm Windows by J. H. Klems. This Berkeley storm window research focuses on north-facing storm windows using low e glazing. It uses rigorous scientific analysis to conclude that no difference is found in performance between the low-e storm with an original window and a low-e replacement window.
Building Regulations and Historic Buildings: balancing the needs for energy conservation with those of building conservation The English Heritage Interim Guidance article touches on all parts of preservation and conservation of power and fuel, and the chapter on windows is very relevant.
Repair or Replace Windows in Historic Buildings: Arriving at a Sustainable Solution The Heritage Canada file contains two articles, one from Andrew Powter and Craig Sims discussing how to arrive at a decision to replace or repair original windows, and Susan Turner explains the sustainable nature of window repair rather than replacement.
Life Cycle Of Window Materials - A Comparative Assessment by Asif, Davidson and Muneer. A comparative life cycle assessment of the environmental impact of different window materials is included for its interesting materials energy cost analysis.
What Replacement Windows Cant Replace: The Real Cost of Replacing Historic Windows Walter Sedovic and Jill Gotthelf provide an excellent discussion of the comparative value of window replacement versus repair. Many aspects of sustainability are considered.
Testing the energy performance of wood windows in Cold Climates by Brad James, Andrew Shapiro, Steve Flanders and Dr. David Hemenway is a thoroughly researched paper that concludes that historic windows should not be replaced for energy considerations alone, as retrofitted and replacement windows perform similarly.
Lincoln Hall Windows Research Report: A Case Study of Options for Treatment for Windows at Lincoln Hall, University Of Illinois, Urbana Champaign This report provides empirical data to assess window repair or replacement options for a proposed LEED Gold project, addressing the existing windows in terms of energy consumption.
"What Shall We Do With Our Windows?" by Gordon Bock, Traditional Building Magazine, October 2014
"Storm Windows Save Energy" Home Energy Magazine, 1/28/14 "Old Windows Find a Following" by Katie Zezima. New York Times 7/27/2011.
Windows Aren't Always A Clear Path for Savings: In Quest to Boost Energy-Efficiency, Small Changes Might Have Bigger Payoff by Terri Rupar.Washington Post5/16/2009.
Thinking Of New Windows? Save Your EnergyNational Public Radio (NPR) 10/11/2009.
"What Should I Do About My Windows?" by Bill Mattinson, Ross DePaola, and Dariush Arasteh for Home Energy Magazine. August 2002
Here is the original post:
WINDOW REPAIR & RETROFIT: STUDIES & RESEARCH
- Ludicrous: bitter row erupts over plan to replace windows at Notre Dame - The Guardian - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Driver Charged For Using Duct Tape As A Window Replacement - muskoka411.com - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Commercial vehicle driver charged for using duct tape as window replacement - CTV News Barrie - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Commercial Vehicle Driver Charged for Using Duct Tape as a Window Replacement - Bayshore Broadcasting News Centre - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Real Madrid Interested In Signing Toni Kroos Replacement In Summer Transfer Window - Sports Illustrated - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- Six moves Chelsea should make during the 2025 January transfer window: Blues must move on the deadwood and find a replacement for unreliable Robert... - January 3rd, 2025 [January 3rd, 2025]
- CCG begins window replacement contract for Partick Housing Association - Scottish Construction Now - December 21st, 2024 [December 21st, 2024]
- Pella vs. Lowes Windows: What to know when buying the big brands - New York Post - November 29th, 2024 [November 29th, 2024]
- You can get massive tax credits for replacing your old windows here's how to collect - The Cool Down - November 29th, 2024 [November 29th, 2024]
- The 5 best window brands to level up your home in 2024 - New York Post - November 29th, 2024 [November 29th, 2024]
- Club searching for replacement as player set to join Southampton in January window - Sport Witness - November 29th, 2024 [November 29th, 2024]
- Boone County Courthouse windows leak after 35 years, replacements are on the way - cnhinews.com - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- Walt's Window Repair & Screening in Coconut Creek Continues Legacy After 45 Years as Business Enters Second Generation of Family Ownership -... - October 28th, 2024 [October 28th, 2024]
- Video art installation in Philadelphia offers a window into 3 cities elsewhere in the world - KYW - October 28th, 2024 [October 28th, 2024]
- I tried replacing the Windows 11 desktop with a web app, and I'm very excited for the future - XDA Developers - October 28th, 2024 [October 28th, 2024]
- BTL Windows and Siding | Window Replacement - WGHP FOX8 Greensboro - October 9th, 2024 [October 9th, 2024]
- How Much Does Main Water Shut-Off Valve Replacement Cost In 2024? - Forbes - October 9th, 2024 [October 9th, 2024]
- Parking impacts: University Bookstore window replacement - Virginia Tech - September 29th, 2024 [September 29th, 2024]
- How much does skylight window installation cost in 2024? Materials, installation and other factors - USA TODAY - September 29th, 2024 [September 29th, 2024]
- Improve the Efficiency of Your Home with Renewal by Andersen's Replacement Window & Doors - ABC Action News Tampa Bay - September 20th, 2024 [September 20th, 2024]
- Robots replace human window washers on skyscrapers - Fox News - September 20th, 2024 [September 20th, 2024]
- Highrise window plunges 30 stories, hits car in San Francisco - NBC Bay Area - September 7th, 2024 [September 7th, 2024]
- Tenant in disbelief after discovering HOA's shortcut with window replacement: 'Odds are they didn't pull a permit' - The Cool Down - September 7th, 2024 [September 7th, 2024]
- Moving to Texas Statistics: Our 2024 Report - USA TODAY - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- The Best Window Brands of August 2024 - MarketWatch - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- 'I have until next week': Toronto condo owner facing $40,000 bill for new windows - CTV News Toronto - August 17th, 2024 [August 17th, 2024]
- New controversy at Notre Dame over stained glass replacement - Aleteia - January 13th, 2024 [January 13th, 2024]
- Pro vs DIY Window Replacement: Which Is Better for Your Home? - FINE Homes and Living - January 5th, 2024 [January 5th, 2024]
- How to replace your broken window - Otago Daily Times - January 5th, 2024 [January 5th, 2024]
- Shop New Windows & Doors | Pella of Naperville - March 24th, 2023 [March 24th, 2023]
- How Much Does Window Glass Replacement Cost? - Bob Vila - November 1st, 2022 [November 1st, 2022]
- Window Replacement - Home Window Replacement & Installation - Window Nation - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- Best Replacement Window Companies Of September 2022 - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- Three Brothers LLC Boise Announces That They Are Offering Peerless Local Window Installation Services - Digital Journal - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- Kingston compensation for woman who waited more than two months for window repair - Surrey Comet - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- What to know as Manitowoc County mulls property tax hike to help fund courthouse renovations expected to exceed $25M - Herald Times Reporter - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- LG wants to replace Metro and other subway train windows with transparent OLED displays - Firstpost - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- New Apodaca art installation showcases the talents of renowned glass artists - Western Carolina University News - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- Jesus joins the Bristol Bus Boycott to replace Colston stained glass window - Bristol Live - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- 5 Things to Know About Owning a Car in This Economy - theSkimm - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- Amazon warehouse robots are getting closer to replacing human hands - Vox.com - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- Avoid auto-installation of Windows Home when installing Windows - Hindu Wire - September 30th, 2022 [September 30th, 2022]
- Spotlight:Six factors that impact the cost of your home window replacement project - CambridgeToday - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- How to Install a Window AC Unit - CNET - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Vandal smashes windows at three Vancouver businesses - The Columbian - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Report: Windows 11 22H2 update will be released on September 20 - Ars Technica - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Why the Bucs should replace Tom Brady with Lamar Jackson in 2023 - Bucs Wire - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Three more players expected to leave Brighton before the end of the summer transfer window - SussexWorld - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Hull firm's pride as installation rating puts it in top bracket for UK window work - Business Live - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Findochty windows: Councillors allow uPVC in conservation area - The Press & Journal - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Analysing all the strikers linked to Man Utd to replace Ronaldo: Morata, Pulisic, Felix, Gakpo and more under the microscope - Goal.com - August 20th, 2022 [August 20th, 2022]
- Fix Windows 11/10 Installation error 0x800F0955 - 0x20003 - TWCN Tech News - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- Window and insulation rebates doubled in Clark County - The Reflector - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- Narrative installation 'Lost in the Woods' taps into art, writing students' talents - Fredonia.edu - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- Groove Music player updated and replaced with new Windows 11 Media Player for some - OnMSFT.com - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- City, Hope Home Repair to part ways The Kansan - Newton Kansan - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- Five players Sheffield Wednesday could sign in January transfer window to replace Theo Corbeanu - Yorkshire Live - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- These two Bergen towns will hold special elections on school repairs costing over $20M - NorthJersey.com - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- Automotive Replacement Glass Windshields Market to Witness Robust Expansion by 2029 | AGC Automotive Replacement Glass, Glass Doctor, Magna ... - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- Army finally picks an optic for Next Generation Squad Weapon - DefenseNews.com - January 12th, 2022 [January 12th, 2022]
- Window Woman to appear on 'This Old House' - The Daily News of Newburyport - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Comment: Another year goes by and Apple still hasnt replaced iTunes on Windows with something better - 9to5Mac - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Knocking over a fan's beer and replacing it has become the hottest trend in pro sports - GolfDigest.com - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- What the Army's Bradley replacement will look like may be decided in 2022 - ArmyTimes.com - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Microsoft's wins, fails, and WTF moments of 2021 - PCWorld - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Spurs can finally replace Toby with 90k-p/w "beast" who has "always been the leader" - opinion - MSN UK - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- The biggest Arizona headlines of 2021, from recycling plant fire to COVID-19 to a partisan election review - The Arizona Republic - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Two And A Half Suggestions For A Manchin-Approved Build Back Better/Social Insurance Program - Forbes - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Rdiger's hopes for Real Madrid move placed on the back burner - AS English - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Replacement Glass Shortage Adding To Woes Of San Francisco Car Break-Ins Victims - CBS San Francisco - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Ask the Remodeler: Replace or refurbish? A look at old windows - The Boston Globe - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Thats The Wijnaldum Replacement Sorted - Pundit On Liverpool Target Youri Tielemans - Sports Illustrated - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Election Results 2021: Voters replace Westminster Mayor, City Council - The Westminster Window - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- State Board of Regents approves additional $770000 for UI Stead Family Children's Hospital windows - UI The Daily Iowan - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Missing person posters replaced with pink balloons in celebration of Cleo Smiths return - WAtoday - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Liverpool have perfect 18m Roberto Firmino replacement ahead of January transfer window - Liverpool.com - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Racing Optics Offers Dealers and Installers Its WINDSHIELD DEFENSE KIT, Which Includes Its Multi-Layer Windshield Film System Which Provides Three... - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Skyscraper Window Washing Robots Are Here to Take Over One of Our Most Terrifying Jobs - Gizmodo - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- 11 Worst Features of Windows 11 and How to Fix Them - Tom's Hardware - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]
- Figge in Davenport makes repairs to its windows and to bridge community gaps - WHBF - OurQuadCities.com - November 4th, 2021 [November 4th, 2021]