Despite critics, Rudys plan passes muster

Posted: Wednesday, November 26, 2014 5:23 pm | Updated: 5:37 pm, Wed Nov 26, 2014.

CAPE ELIZABETH - A new, modern version of the Rudys of the Cape restaurant got mostly positive support from residents and the Cape Elizabeth Planning Board during a hearing on an updated site plan for the property Nov. 18.

But some residents, and one Planning Board member, continue to criticize the proposal. They say the new Rudys design is not compatible with other nearby buildings on Ocean House Road, better known as Route 77.

In a 5-1-1 vote, with Chairwoman Victoria Volent abstaining, the Planning Board approved several modifications to a previously approved site plan and resource protection permit for Rudys, including upgrades to lighting and curbing, the installation of raised planters, a generator, an entrance sign and more.

Because this was an amendment to a standing approval, they should be able to continue full throttle or at a speed the owner dictates on the project, while the plans are updated, Town Planner Maureen OMeara said after the meeting.

Part of the proposal, which is to use weathered steel siding on the lower portion of the building, has triggered mixed reviews from residents.

We have heard very different points of view from the public, said Planning Board member Elaine Falendar. Weve had as many emails in opposition as weve had speakers in support (of the project.)

While some residents say they love the one-and-a-half story, contemporary, cottage-style building that replaces the former Rudys diner and convenience store, others would prefer a design they say would blend in with Cape Elizabeths existing architecture.

I think if you look at it at the right angle, it looks like Darth Vaders helmet, resident Todd Colpitts said of the building. I do not think its compatible with the structures in the neighborhood.

Henry Steinberg, the only member who voted against the modified site plan, said Cape Elizabeth is a calm and relaxed community that projects an aura of tranquility.

The rest is here:
Despite critics, Rudys plan passes muster