After decades of rent control, New York City is a perfect case study on the unintended consequences of artificial rent ceilings. The citys system has contributed to soaring rents by removing stabilized apartments from the supply-side of the market, becoming a major driver of the affordable housing crisis. Meanwhile, the condition of stabilized dwellings which make up almost half of our housing stock has fallen woefully behind market-rate standards as expenses rise faster than rents.
Ironically, while any microeconomics text will demonstrate how rent ceilings cause housing shortages, it seems that the longer New Yorks rent controls are in effect and the more the gap between the price and quality of stabilized dwellings and their free-market counterparts grows, the stronger the political will becomes to add fuel to the fire by imposing even more rent control. Todays political agenda increasingly favors strengthening the existing system, as evidenced by the passing of Junes Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act. In its aftermath, New Yorks tenant coalition and members of the city council want to take things even further and broaden rent control laws to regulate free market apartments and commercial spaces by means of the Good Cause Eviction Bill and the Small Business Jobs Survival Act.
Good Cause Eviction amounts to universal rent control. It would limit rent increases on free market units to 1.5 times that years growth in the consumer price index and take away an owners ability to evict a tenant for anything other than what the law deems good cause, for example extended arrears or criminal activity. The Small Business Jobs Survival Act is commercial rent control and would apply to retail spaces of 10,000 square feet or less and to industrial and office spaces of 25,000 square feet or less and introduce a rent guidelines board to oversee allowable rent increases. It would also give tenants in these spaces an automatic 10-year lease renewal option and force both parties into arbitration if they cannot agree on the rent increase. Both bills would drastically shift the balance of power away from landlords and toward tenants. Similar to rent stabilization, these far reaching changes would remove landlords financial incentives to invest in improvements and renovations and more than likely send most of New Yorks building stock on a gradual descent into the same disrepair and neglect as stabilized housing has experienced.
Imposing universal rent control would close the city off to most newcomers and much of the talent pool which makes NYC so attractive to new business. In the same way rent stabilization has driven up prices for free-market apartments, curbing rent growth on all units would act like rocket fuel to the price of vacant units. Over time, tenants with below market rents would face a growing incentive to stay put, keeping more units out of the markets supply side. In addition, most owners fortunate enough to have a vacancy would have an incentive to hold out for the highest rent possible and to think long and hard before committing to a new lease since doing so would mean signing a contract with no end date. The process of finding an affordable place to live under those circumstances would be excruciating.
The effects of commercial rent control would mirror those of universal rent control, making it exceedingly difficult and expensive to rent commercial space while hurting the types of businesses the bill purports to help. Giving tenants a legal right to indefinite renewal terms would make landlords reluctant to rent to small business owners who lack a demonstrated track record of success or a deep reserve of capital. It would also amplify the risk of renting space at below market rent, giving owners little choice but to keep space vacant for extended periods of time while they search for a perfect match.
The natural evolution of the citys commercial landscape would grind to a halt depriving our communities from having the shops, amenities and entertainment that they desire. In a free-market economy, people vote with their wallets. Market rents are a function of what businesses which successfully serve consumers are willing to pay for space. If the community isnt willing to pay enough for a businesss services to cover the rent, then that business is no longer the locations highest and best use. Instead of allowing a better suited enterprise to take its place, commercial rent control would force a suboptimal and outdated use on the community and force the buildings owner to subsidize its existence with rent concessions.
At the heart of New Yorks real estate affordability crisis is a supply and demand disparity between those who need space and the available space to go around. Instead of addressing the issue by adding to the supply by encouraging more housing density and development, broadening rent control to free market and commercial spaces has the potential to stop most new development altogether. The vast majority of new construction within the city limits is in fact redevelopment involving sites already occupied by obsolete or underdeveloped structures. Giving practically all tenants an indefinite right of possession beyond their original lease term would render most of these sites unbuildable as vacating them becomes cost prohibitive. Imagine the cost of negotiating a commercial tenant buy-out where that tenant is legally entitled to a 10-year renewal.
While the intent of both bills is to protect renters, their passage would harm the citys real estate stock, its future development potential and compound its affordable housing crisis. What makes New York a leading world city is its ability to attract new talent, business and investment from all over the globe. The city relies on this ability to fuel its economy, jobs and tax revenues. Signing these bills into law would signal to the world that New York City is closed for business and to newcomers.
Jakub Nowak is a Senior Vice President Investments, Team Leader and Associate Real Estate Broker at The Nowak Group of Marcus & Millichap.
View post:
The Threat to NYC's Growth, Affordability and Quality of Life - Commercial Observer
- Proposed New Albany mixed-use project could add 104 homes, retail space off US 62 - The Columbus Dispatch - February 16th, 2025 [February 16th, 2025]
- McLaren to build top-down on 60m New Bond Street contract - Construction Enquirer - January 31st, 2025 [January 31st, 2025]
- Nearly 300-unit complex, retail space breaks ground along Delmar Loop, is expected to boost business - First Alert 4 - January 31st, 2025 [January 31st, 2025]
- Chicago approves $7-billion 1901 Project near United Center - Chicago Construction News - January 21st, 2025 [January 21st, 2025]
- New year forecast to be big for Austin-area retail construction - The Business Journals - January 13th, 2025 [January 13th, 2025]
- With housing and retail, the next big Wilmington project has a new construction timeline - StarNewsOnline.com - November 21st, 2024 [November 21st, 2024]
- Limited Construction Will Drive Retail, Industrial Performance - Globe St. - November 21st, 2024 [November 21st, 2024]
- A $23 million apartment complex promises to bring new vitality to quaint Swedesboro, N.J. But is there enough parking? - The Philadelphia Inquirer - November 21st, 2024 [November 21st, 2024]
- Developer seeks to build 7 new retail spaces on Staten Island Mall property - SILive.com - October 28th, 2024 [October 28th, 2024]
- From bread to batting cages: Old Sunbeam bakery building could have a bright future - SouthCoastToday.com - October 28th, 2024 [October 28th, 2024]
- The Shops at Indian Creek Will Bring Grocery Store, Retail Space to Henry County - What Now Atlanta - September 7th, 2024 [September 7th, 2024]
- Developer proposing to build thousands of homes, retail space in Dixon - ABC10.com KXTV - September 7th, 2024 [September 7th, 2024]
- Santander to convert its office space in Miami into 41-story tower with combined office and retail space - Santander - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- 46-acre project off I-495 expected to add housing, retail, jobs in Littleton - MassLive.com - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- The value of building work in the commercial construction pipeline is slowing - Interest.co.nz - August 25th, 2024 [August 25th, 2024]
- New center will bring shops to area near Meyerland Plaza - Houston Chronicle - August 17th, 2024 [August 17th, 2024]
- Anytime Fitness withdraws from Weston site, building expands from 3 tenants to 4 - WSAW - August 17th, 2024 [August 17th, 2024]
- Transforming Former Retail Spaces into Outpatient Facilities - Healthcare Construction and Operations News - June 24th, 2024 [June 24th, 2024]
- Construction begins on apartments, retail space in Bellanca building - Cabin Radio - April 25th, 2024 [April 25th, 2024]
- City financing proposed for The Ave - Urbanize LA - April 25th, 2024 [April 25th, 2024]
- Leveraging Commercial Construction Expertise for Business Growth in London - London Post - March 23rd, 2024 [March 23rd, 2024]
- Kittery, Maine will demolish one of its outlet malls to make room for new housing - WBUR News - March 5th, 2024 [March 5th, 2024]
- Work Resumes on 550 Tenth Avenue After Crane Collapse in Hell's ... - New York YIMBY - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Bill Rudin Stepping Down as CEO of Rudin Management - The Real Deal - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Kaplan Survives Appeals Against Woodland Hills Development - The Real Deal - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Related, W5 Building Wynwood Co-Living Project - The Real Deal - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- What's next for Waterfront development on Allentown riverfront? - The Morning Call - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Clean Buildings bill might get messy for commercial property owners - Spokane Journal of Business - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- M&T Bank Lends $30M on 111 West 57th Street Tower - Commercial Observer - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Shoma Doubles Height, Expands Project on US 1, Bird in Miami - The Real Deal - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Town of Andover Awarded $3.3 Million MassWorks Grant for ... - Andover, MA - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Settlement reached in ballpark construction in CT city - Hartford Courant - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Launch of Leasing Announced For Swanky New Gowanus Office ... - BK Reader - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- MAD architects will perch a futuristic 'ark' atop a cement factory ruin ... - Designboom - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Moab climbing gym in the works - Moab Sun News - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Heres the latest on the new mixed-use, transit-oriented development coming to Nubian Square - Boston.com - November 18th, 2022 [November 18th, 2022]
- Historic renovation to begin in downtown OKC in March 2023 - KOKH FOX25 - November 18th, 2022 [November 18th, 2022]
- STRATUS PROPERTIES INC Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations. (form 10-Q) - Marketscreener.com - November 18th, 2022 [November 18th, 2022]
- Why a 450,000-square-foot office building in Plymouth is about to meet the wrecking ball - Star Tribune - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Skokie hotel expected to boost downtown area; construction starting - Chicago Tribune - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Here's when the St. Louis area's newest Costco is set to open - KSDK.com - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- 12 latest commercial permits filed in Conroe, including First Watch and Walk On's Bistreaux & Bar - Community Impact Newspaper - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Construction Poised to Begin on $1.2b North Sydney Tower - The Urban Developer - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Project of the Month: Ayr Wellness opens dispensary in Watertown - built by Connolly Brothers; designed by Scott/Griffin Architects - New England Real... - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Brookridge project could break ground in Overland Park this fall - Shawnee Mission Post - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Sunday Summary: Back to the Office Commercial Observer - Commercial Observer - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- US 1 is getting a public square | CNU - Congress for the New Urbanism - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Rockefeller, Park Tower land $200M to build at Greenpoint Landing - The Real Deal - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Developers seek to build 264 apartments near Jeffersonville Town Center - Yahoo News - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- 32 Hoboken + Jersey City News Stories You Missed This Week - hobokengirl.com - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Vacation resort planned for northwest Cape Coral | News, Sports, Jobs - Pineisland Eagle - Pine Island Eagle - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- Commentary: Will Housing Bills Help Address Housing Shortfalls? - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - September 5th, 2022 [September 5th, 2022]
- New Construction? S. Fla. Is Almost Out of Land - | Florida Realtors - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Newburgh warehouses add to steady development in Orange County - Times Herald-Record - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Retail vendors, restaurants, food trucks: New Ocala Mall will be housed in old Ocala Kmart - Ocala - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Northland Acquires Land at Corner of 17th and Spring Streets For Multifamily Project - What Now Atlanta - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Post Brothers Closes $400M Construction Loan for Philly Megaproject - Commercial Observer - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Beechwood going big with multiple projects in North Carolina - Long Island Business News - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Some arent ready to close curtain on Varsity Theater for proposed apartment development - Evanston RoundTable - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- DMCC's Uptown Tower tops out at 329m, steel crown to complete in Q1 2022 - Construction Week Online - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Construction at massive new CSULB art museum promises more art and community inclusion the Hi-lo - Long Beach Post - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- ASU alum builds rewarding construction career from ground up - ASU Now - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- $100 million apartment building coming to Center City in 2023 - PhillyVoice.com - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Enclave starts big expansion of Uptown & Main in southwest Fargo - INFORUM - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Facebook Is Getting Into the Real Estate Business - Architectural Digest - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Point Square hits the market with 75m price tag - The Irish Times - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Strongsville voters to determine future of townhomes-retail project at Ohio 82 and Prospect Road - cleveland.com - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Housing Takes the Podium Eugene Weekly - Eugene Weekly - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Hotel addition that could be downtown's new largest building passes Asheville planning board - Citizen Times - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Fight over Utah Theatre will likely flare up this week. How did we get here? - buildingsaltlake.com - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Gables Residential Breaks Ground on New Development in Washington, DC - PR Web - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Former heating, plumbing supply building site of mixed-use proposal - Herald-Whig - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Rutgers Cancer Institute of New Jersey and RWJBarnabas Health Leader Recognized as NJBIZ 2021 Healthcare Hero - Newswise - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Mayor Bowser Cuts Ribbon on New All Affordable Senior Housing Honoring the Late Todd A. Lee | mayormb - Executive Office of the Mayor - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Construction sector projected to grow by 3.9 per - architects - The Star, Kenya - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Drexel came through the pandemic better than expected. Now president John Fry is contemplating his next step. - The Philadelphia Inquirer - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- St. Augustine plans traffic upgrade for busy intersection of Wildwood Drive and US 1 South - St. Augustine Record - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- Lowe Debuts Assembly 127-unit Apartment Building in Oakland's Uptown District - Business Wire - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- WilmingtonBiz Talk: Downtown update - Greater Wilmington Business Journal - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- In The Pipeline: Top Projects Coming To D.C.'s Southwest Waterfront - Bisnow - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]