Quay white elephant warning

The proposed building for Perth. Pictures: Unique 8 Design Studio

Top Perth architects have warned against rushing to build an iconic building at Elizabeth Quay, saying it could be a costly white elephant if not done right.

They believe the best landmark buildings were not designed as icons but became so because they fit the location, filled a need and used world-class architects.

Debate over what sort of building should be put up on nearly 50,000sqm of prime waterfront real estate was ignited this week when Burswood designer Shane O'Riley unveiled his unsolicited vision for a new concert hall.

The skeletal-style design split public opinion, with some likening it to an elephant graveyard or a rack of lamb, while others hailed it as a bold piece of architecture.

The Elizabeth Quay master plan has the space earmarked for an indigenous culture, arts and learning centre.

University of WA dean of architecture Simon Anderson said Mr O'Riley's design was "just an idea" but reaffirmed the view a "major sculptural cultural building would be a good thing".

He pointed to modern Chinese cultural centres as an example of well-executed sculptural design.

"Given that the building will be seen from above - from Kings Park and the towers in the city - it will always require a 3D form," Mr Anderson said.

He said the prominence of the site was akin to that occupied by Sydney Opera House but he cautioned against a city-defining building for the sake of it.

Here is the original post:
Quay white elephant warning